Silicone Teether vs. Wooden Teether: Which Is Better for Your Teething Baby?

Quick answer

For most babies, a silicone teether is the safer, more hygienic choice because it's soft on gums, easy to sterilize, and free of harmful chemicals. Wooden teethers are a natural, eco-friendly option but require more care and can't be boiled or washed as easily. Choose silicone for everyday teething relief, and consider wood if you prefer a sustainable material and are diligent about cleaning.

Teething is a tough phase for both babies and parents. Sore gums, drooling, and fussy nights can leave everyone exhausted. One of the most effective ways to soothe your little one is with a teether, but with so many materials on the market, it's hard to know which is best.

In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences between silicone and wooden teethers, including safety, cleaning, durability, and how each feels on sore gums. We'll also highlight a few specific products to help you make an informed choice for your baby.

Safety and Materials

Safety is the top priority when choosing anything for your baby. Silicone teethers, like the Silicone Teether from Lalo, are made with FDA grade non-toxic silicone. That means they're free from BPA, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals, making them a safe choice for your baby to chew on. They're also soft and flexible, which is gentle on tender gums.

Wooden teethers, on the other hand, are often made from natural hardwoods and finished with food-safe oils or waxes. They're generally safe, but you need to check the finish to ensure it's non-toxic. Wood is also harder than silicone, which can be too firm for some babies, especially during early teething when gums are most sensitive. Always inspect wooden teethers for splinters or cracks.

• Always check for safety certifications like FDA approval or non-toxic labels.
• Inspect wooden teethers regularly for splinters or damage.

Cleaning and Hygiene

Babies put everything in their mouths, so keeping teethers clean is essential. Silicone teethers are a clear winner here. They're non-porous, so they don't harbor bacteria, and they can be easily washed with soap and water, or even popped in the dishwasher or sterilizer. This makes them a hygienic choice for daily use.

Wooden teethers are porous, which means they can absorb moisture and harbor bacteria if not dried properly. They also can't be boiled, put in the dishwasher, or soaked, as that can damage the wood and finish. Instead, you need to wipe them down with a damp cloth and mild soap, then dry them thoroughly. This extra care is a tradeoff for the natural material.

Durability and Longevity

Silicone is incredibly durable and can withstand lots of chewing. It's resistant to bites and won't break easily, making it a long-lasting option that can even be used for multiple children. The Silicone Teether from Lalo is also the perfect size for little hands to hold, so it's easy for your baby to grip and chew.

Wooden teethers are also durable, but they can show wear over time. They might develop bite marks, and if the finish wears off, the wood can become rough. They also need to be replaced if they crack or splinter. While wood is biodegradable and eco-friendly, it may not last as long as silicone in the long run.

The tradeoffs at a glance

• Silicone teether: Soft, flexible, and gentle on gums. Non-porous and easy to clean. Can be sterilized. Durable and long-lasting. Best for everyday teething relief and easy hygiene.
• Wooden teether: Natural and eco-friendly. Harder texture may not suit all babies. Requires careful cleaning to avoid bacteria buildup. Choose wood if you prioritize sustainability and don't mind extra care.
• Cleaning effort: Silicone is dishwasher safe and quick to clean. Wood needs hand washing and thorough drying. If you're short on time, silicone wins on convenience.

Products we recommend

• Silicone Teether: Made with FDA grade non-toxic silicone, the Silicone Teether is safe for soothing gums and the perfect size for little hands to hold. This teether is not only safe but also easy for your baby to grip, making it a practical choice for daily teething relief.
• Polar Bear Sailing Boat: Made with PlanWood that is waterproof and perfect for bathtub or outdoor play. If you're considering a wooden option, this boat offers a waterproof alternative for teething during bath time, though it's not specifically a teether.

Which teether is right for your baby?

Best for

• Parents who want a low-maintenance, hygienic teether that's easy to clean.
• Babies who are in the early teething stage and need a soft, gentle surface for sore gums.

Not for

• Parents who prefer natural, eco-friendly materials and are willing to put in extra cleaning effort.
• Babies who are heavy chewers and might benefit from a firmer texture, though silicone is still durable.

In the silicone vs. wooden teether debate, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Silicone offers superior hygiene, safety, and ease of use, making it a great everyday choice for most families. Wooden teethers are a lovely natural option, but they demand more care. Consider your baby's needs and your lifestyle to pick the best teether for your little one's teething journey.